Is the JCPenney Rewards Credit Card Worth It?

If you’re already a regular shopper with JCPenney, you’ve probably been asked at the checkout if you’d like to apply for their JCPenney Rewards Credit Card before. We admit it seems like a pretty good deal with its extra discounts, rewards points, and special financing offers. But is it actually worth signing up for? And are there drawbacks you need to be aware of?

In this guide, we'll take you through all the perks and features of the store-only JCPenney Rewards Credit Card and the Mastercard. Have a read and discover which one best suits your wallet and your shopping habits.

Overview of the JCPenney Rewards Credit Card

Synchrony Bank issues the JCPenney Rewards Credit Card, and it comes in two forms to suit your shopping style:

  • JCPenney Store Card: You can only use this version at JCPenney stores, JCP.com, Sephora inside JCPenney, Sephora.com, and Rite Aid.
  • JCPenney Mastercard: You can shop with this anywhere Mastercard is accepted, so there's a bit more flexibility with your spending.

The biggest bonus is that there's no annual fee for either card, so straight away you're avoiding extra costs. When you first open your account, you'll get a special promotional discount that ranges from 5% to 35% off your first purchase. However, the exact amount depends on what you're buying. For example, you might get 35% off fine jewelry or 25% off if you're paying for salon services.

You'll need a fair credit score (around 640 or higher) to qualify for either. We recommend checking if you prequalify online before you apply, as this won't affect your credit score, which is a smart move before applying.

Cardholder Status and Rewards Structure

Once you have the card, you can start earning rewards points:

  • 1.5 points per $1 spent at JCPenney stores or online.
  • 1 point per $5 spent elsewhere if you have the Mastercard version.

Keep in mind that you can earn a maximum of 2,000 points per transaction. Points convert at a rate of 200 points = $10 in JCPenney CashPass Rewards, which equals about 5% back on JCPenney purchases.

So, if you spend $100 at JCPenney, you'll get 150 points. And when you hit 200 points, you'll get a $10 reward. It's pretty straightforward, but it'll only pay off if you shop there often enough to build up your rewards quickly.

JCPenney Credit Card Benefits

One of the biggest drawcards to any credit card is the potential rewards it offers the cardholder. Here’s what to expect when you get your hands on a JCPenney Credit Card to see if it’s a good fit for you.

New Cardholder Discount

Ready to sign up and make your first purchase? You could get a one-time discount ranging from 5% to 35%, depending on the item category. Here's some examples:

  • 35% off fine jewelry
  • 25% off salon services
  • 15% off apparel and accessories
  • 5% off select electronics

Sure, this is a nice introductory perk, especially if you're planning a big purchase. But remember, it's a one-time offer. After that, you'll need to rely on the regular reward structure and occasional promotions to get more bang for your buck.

Accelerated Rewards & Birthday Bonus

When you shop with the JCPenney card, you earn rewards 50% faster than standard JCPenney Rewards members. So, you'll get more CashPass points in your account faster. You'll also get a $10 CashPass Reward for your birthday, so don't forget to enter your birthdate in your rewards profile.

The card also gets you access to exclusive bonus events, with things like extra points days and extra discounts. But, since the CashPass rewards expire 45 days after issue and your points expire 12 months after you earn them, you need to get in quick and use them before they're gone.

Special Financing Options

Planning a large purchase? The JCPenney card might help with financing major items like furniture and appliances. You can choose from these two offers:

  • No interest if you pay in full within a set period (e.g., 18 months on purchases over $499).
  • Deferred interest promotions. You won't pay interest during the promo period, but if you haven't paid the full balance by the end, they'll charge you all the interest retroactively from the purchase date.

However, this is a tricky option, and you need to be careful. If you happen to slip up and not pay in full by the deadline, you could face a whopping 34.99% APR. You'll wipe out any rewards you've earned and get a huge bill.

Drawbacks of the Card

The JCPenney Rewards Credit Card has some great benefits if you're a frequent shopper. But, there's also some downsides to weigh up before signing up:

  • Limited reward redemption: Remember, you can only use your rewards at JCPenney. Looking for flexible cash back or travel rewards? This card won't deliver.
  • Points cap per transaction: Even when you make a large purchase, you'll only earn rewards on up to 2,000 points per transaction.
  • Low rewards rate outside JCPenney: Since you earn just 1 point per $5 you spend elsewhere, the Mastercard version isn't that great when compared to other general cash-back cards.
  • High interest rate: The APR can be a whopping 35% when you carry over a balance. So, it’s significantly higher than the average credit card.

If you typically carry a balance or want to earn rewards that you can use beyond a single store, you are better off with a general cash back credit card. Shop around and compare the options. These days, there are lots of cards that offer 1.5% to 2% back on all purchases, and they also come with a stack of welcome bonuses and flexible rewards.

How to Apply or Prequalify

Drawbacks aside, there are plenty of reasons why the JCPenney Rewards Credit Card should be in your wallet. Ready to see if you qualify? Here's how you can apply:

  1. Visit the JCPenney Credit Card site.
  2. Click on "Apply Now" or "See if you prequalify."
  3. Fill out your information, including your income and Social Security number.
  4. If you prequalify, they'll invite you to complete a full application.

Prequalification is a great way to test the waters without making a mark on your credit score. Once approved, you can start using your JCPenney discount right away when you shop online or in-store.

Final Verdict: Is It Worth It?

The JCPenney Rewards Credit Card is worth considering if you’re a loyal JCPenney shopper. And it's even better if you're someone who pays off balances in full and wants to save on purchases and rack up store rewards. However, for shoppers who tend to carry balances or rarely shop at JCPenney, there might be better options.

Choosing a card with more flexible rewards, like a general cash back credit card, could be more your style. When your credit card suits your shopping and financial habits, you'll be able to use it much more responsibly and reap all the rewards.

about the author

Clay Cary
Senior Trends Analyst
As an e-commerce analyst at CouponFollow, Clay enjoys spending his time collaborating with brands to make helpful content for consumers and finding great deals to share on CouponFollow. As a recent college graduate, his primary focus is creating resources for consumers, especially students, to save money through online shopping and everyday life.